Reality Panic

The Reality Panic blog has been moved to its dedicated domain.


Major Problem With Women's List...

Spurred by the original "hot 100 developers" list (which only had one female on it), Next-Gen in coordination with Women in Games International has now released the "Game Industry's 100 Most Influential Women" list. And, I've got a real problem with this list...

It needs to be longer!!! Reading through the list is totally inspiring and serves as an eye-opener to all the great women, many in very key roles, that are part of the industry. However, I can rattle off a whole bunch more that aren't on the list (without even breaking a sweat).

And so, here's my quick extension to the list:

Of course, there's tons more, but those are the ones right off the top of my head :)

Also, kudos to Jane McGonigal for being named a Young Innovator by MIT's Technology Review. The only game related person to make the list - a female no less :)

Posted on September 12, 2006 02:37 PM

Comments

I agree with your extensions, and it's actually good to see that the list CAN be extended.

One person I feel is missing, even though she is not involved with games anymore - Roberta Williams. If we are going with the most INFLUENTIAL women in games, then I think Roberta Williams takes the cake. I know that there are a TON of game developers of both genders in the industry today that were inspired by her games, and that should be enough to put her on the list.

Posted by: Luke at September 12, 2006 03:32 PM


Wow. I can't believe that most of those women you listed AREN'T on the list. I'm gonna have to go read it and see who they DID put on!

Posted by: Darius K. at September 12, 2006 05:05 PM


great picks.
but i disagree...i think the list should have been shorter. i felt like there was a lot of filler in there.
clan leaders?
or maybe take the filler out and put in all the hunickes and pinckards.

(atleast heather was in there!)

Posted by: fish at September 13, 2006 10:01 AM


I totally agree the list was lacking. I just sent the following note to Next-Gen:


"Shame on Next-Gen for leaving Libe Goad, easily the most important mainstream female games journalist on the country, off your list. Libe runs the editorial side of AOL Games, and also writes the games section for Blender, one of the biggest mainstream entertainment mags on newsstands.


She is a regular TV talking head as well, most recently appearing on G4's "Attack of the Show" this week.


Before joining AOL, Libe ran the games section of Sync magazine, was an editor at HappyPuppy.com, ran the games section of Kozmo.com and co-founded the influential girls gaming site GameGal.com (one of PC Magazine's Top 100 sites of 2002)."

Posted by: Dan at September 13, 2006 01:10 PM


Maybe one of you smart people might have thought to produce your own list, assuming that you wanted to spend, literally, weeks slogging through this incredibly challenging feature. You might then find yourself "breaking into sweat". We have asked for additions and received some, and will publish them, but "shame on Next Gen"? Gimme a break.

Posted by: Colin Campbell at September 13, 2006 01:27 PM


@Dan

Pimping your GF? Tasteful.

Posted by: Steve at September 13, 2006 03:42 PM


@Colin,

FWIW, my title/"complaint" was in jest...

Alas, we need to remember that this is a good problem (ie, we've got more great women in games than can fit on a list of only 100 ;)

Jason

Posted by: Jason Della Rocca at September 13, 2006 05:26 PM


From what I heard, a request for bios and headshots was sent out to a large array of worthy people, and those who returned them got on the list - at least, within the CMP office, that was the case. Hopefully an addendum would include those people who are worthy but weren't contactable or able to provide information.

Posted by: simonc at September 13, 2006 06:20 PM


I did a quick numerical breakdown of the list on my blog.

Posted by: Darius K. at September 13, 2006 08:12 PM


What's kinda frustrating is that I mentioned several of these women in an email to Fiona when she put out her call. I know they had a deadline, and I hope it is just that they didn't get a reply so didn't feel comfortable listing people who hadn't replied to them... but damn. You'd think they could have at least done a list of names of ladies they tried to contact but didn't hear back from. I was really frustrated that Roberta Williams was missing, and Clarinda too. I think the list itself was a terrific idea, and certainly it's a big job... but I think deserving of a more thorough treatment than this. I hope they do follow up with some detail.

Posted by: Erin Hoffman at September 16, 2006 08:48 PM


A quick note, to clear any confusion... Nearly 400 people were initially contacted via e-mail, either be interviewed or to provide suggestions. Anyone who did not respond was e-mailed at least 2 more times, if not more, often at alternate addresses or through 3rd parties. In certain cases, I and our researchers got on the phone to track down key people. While it would have been easy to feature the "usual suspects," it was important that the final list was both diverse AND fair in featuring people we never hear about...it was not intended to focus on cliques. A number of people, inlcuding Clarinda Merripen, chose not to be included. Regarding Roberta Williams, it is well known that she has been retired from games for nearly a decade and is not necessarily creating an immediate impact on the industry. There are numerous other women important to the evolution of games who have exited the industry for other careers, retired or are deceased, all of whom were not mentioned.

Posted by: Fiona Cherbak at September 21, 2006 12:08 AM